Waselius & Wist Navigation
  • Our team
  • In Focus
    • Recent Work
    • News
    • Legal Updates
    • Publications
    • Rankings
    • Blog
    • Newsletter
  • About Us
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Expertise
    • Banking and Finance
    • Capital Markets
    • Corporate and Commercial
    • Corporate governance and Investigations
    • Data Protection
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment and Incentives
    • Energy and Natural Resources
    • EU and Competition
    • Financial Regulatory and Compliance
    • Insurance
    • Intellectual Property and Technology
    • Marketing
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Restructuring and Insolvency
    • Tax and Structuring
  • Careers
    • Lawyers
    • Law students
    • Support staff
    • Open Positions
    • Contact
  • Contact
  • Our team
  • In Focus
    • Recent Work
    • News
    • Legal Updates
    • Publications
    • Rankings
    • Blog
    • Newsletter
  • About Us
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Expertise
    • Banking and Finance
    • Capital Markets
    • Corporate and Commercial
    • Corporate governance and Investigations
    • Data Protection
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment and Incentives
    • Energy and Natural Resources
    • EU and Competition
    • Financial Regulatory and Compliance
    • Insurance
    • Intellectual Property and Technology
    • Marketing
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Restructuring and Insolvency
    • Tax and Structuring
  • Careers
    • Lawyers
    • Law students
    • Support staff
    • Open Positions
    • Contact
  • Contact
In Focus
Home In Focus Asphalt Cartel Results in Highest Ever Fines

Legal Updates15.10.2009

Asphalt Cartel Results in Highest Ever Fines

The Finnish Supreme Administrative Court has recently issued its awaited decision in the largest cartel case tried to date in Finland, dismissing the asphalt companies’ appeals of the Market Court’s decision of 2007 and approving to a significant extent the appeal by the Finnish Competition Authority.

In its decision of 29 September 2009, the Court ruled that virtually all major undertakings in the field, i.e., Lemminkäinen Oyj, Valtatie Oy, Skanska Asfaltti Oy, NCC Roads Oy, SA-Capital Oy, Rudus Asfaltti Oy and Super Asfaltti Oy, had participated between 1994 and 2002 in a nationwide cartel aiming at the removal of effective competition from the Finnish asphalt market, where the largest customers were municipalities and other public bodies.

The total amount of fines, EUR 82.5 million, imposed by the Court is significantly higher than the fine of total of EUR 19.4 million imposed by the Market Court some two years earlier, and represents only a slight reduction from the amount originally proposed by the Finnish Competition Authority.

Apart from the unprecedented level of competition infringement fines imposed on cartel participants, the Court noted that it can be difficult to obtain evidence on cartel behaviour and that evidence presented in cases relating to alleged competition infringements cannot be subject to the same requirements as in criminal cases. Consequently, the Court, most notably, established that evidence must be looked at as a whole without having to prove each single event/action forming a cartel. The Court accepted in this respect that similar events and similar market behaviour taking place at approximately the same time as well as other circumstantial evidence, in the absence of any other plausible explanation, can amount to sufficient evidence of a competition infringement. When assessing the length of a competition infringement, the Court concluded that it was sufficient to show evidence that timewise closely relates to the established facts of the case in order to be able to reasonably conclude that the competition infringement has continued without interruptions between the commencement and the termination thereof.

Therefore, whilst it was established that the Finnish Competition Authority had not been able to obtain conclusive evidence, either geographically or timewise, on all events that had taken place in the relevant market, the Court reasoned that similar events and behaviour by various cartel participants in the market could not have occurred merely by coincidence. Consequently, in the absence of any other plausible evidence or explanation, the Court ruled that the cartel was nationwide and not confined to certain geographical areas nor did it only cover certain segments in the Finnish asphalt market.

The Court’s ruling represents a departure from the approach adopted by the Market Court and facilitates the follow-on claims for damages which have been pending before various local courts waiting for the Court’s ruling.

Going forward, this ruling can be seen to set clearer boundaries as to what is required in terms of sufficient evidence to show the existence of a cartel. The ruling is also bound to induce a change of strategy for cartel participants, both in terms of assessing leniency as an alternative and considering defense strategies.

For further information, please contact any of your usual contacts at our competition team.

Share:
Image

Contact info

Eteläesplanadi 24 A
00130 Helsinki, Finland

+358 9 668 9520
+358 9 668 95 222
ww@ww.fi

Quick links

  • Our Team
  • In Focus
  • About Us
  • Expertise
  • Careers

E-invoicing

E-address: 003710525214
Operator: Apix Messaging Oy
Service ID: 003723327487


BUSINESS ID 1052521-4
VAT ID FI10525214

Legal notice
Privacy notice
General Terms and Conditions

© 2022 Waselius & Wist

This website uses cookies to compile statistical data on the use of our website in order to enable us to evaluate and improve our site. OK Decline Cookie Policy
Manage Cookies

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT