Waselius & Wist Navigation
  • Our team
  • In Focus
    • Recent Work
    • News
    • Legal Updates
    • Publications
    • Rankings
    • Blog
    • Newsletter
  • About Us
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Expertise
    • Banking and Finance
    • Capital Markets
    • Corporate and Commercial
    • Corporate governance and Investigations
    • Data Protection
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment and Incentives
    • Energy and Natural Resources
    • EU and Competition
    • Financial Regulatory and Compliance
    • Insurance
    • Intellectual Property and Technology
    • Marketing
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Restructuring and Insolvency
    • Tax and Structuring
  • Careers
    • Lawyers
    • Law students
    • Support staff
    • Open Positions
    • Contact
  • Contact
  • Our team
  • In Focus
    • Recent Work
    • News
    • Legal Updates
    • Publications
    • Rankings
    • Blog
    • Newsletter
  • About Us
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Expertise
    • Banking and Finance
    • Capital Markets
    • Corporate and Commercial
    • Corporate governance and Investigations
    • Data Protection
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment and Incentives
    • Energy and Natural Resources
    • EU and Competition
    • Financial Regulatory and Compliance
    • Insurance
    • Intellectual Property and Technology
    • Marketing
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Restructuring and Insolvency
    • Tax and Structuring
  • Careers
    • Lawyers
    • Law students
    • Support staff
    • Open Positions
    • Contact
  • Contact
In Focus
Home In Focus Waselius & Wist secures major victory for hospital supply companies

Recent Work24.11.2016

Waselius & Wist secures major victory for hospital supply companies

Waselius & Wist successfully represented Bayer Oy, Oy SCA Hygiene Products Ab, Coloplast Oy and Steripolar Oy as appellants in proceedings in the Supreme Administrative Court (“SAC”) against KL-Kuntahankinnat Oy as contracting authority and OneMed Oy as the winning tenderer. To the extent known, this is the first time a Finnish court has considered a framework arrangement restrictive of competition in a situation where the contracting authority received two competing tenders that fulfilled the requirements of the request for tenders. The decision of the SAC (KHO:2016:182, 17.11.2016) was published in the yearbook of the SAC, which means that it is considered a legal precedent to be followed in other similar cases.

The case concerned an appeal against the procurement of health care supplies and related services by KL-Kuntahankinnat Oy through a framework agreement open for all Finnish municipalities and also certain other contracting authorities. KL-Kuntahankinnat Oy is a central purchasing body acting on behalf of municipal and local government customers by tendering framework agreements, conducting negotiations and managing contracts. The appellants are manufacturers of various hospital and health care supplies.

The estimated total value of the framework agreement was, according to the contracting authority, some 16 million euros. However, since the framework arrangement was open-ended, this figure was according to the appellants not reliable and the actual value of the agreement could have been significantly higher. Eventually, in the absence of the SAC’s intervention, the scope of the agreement could have been nationwide corresponding to a value of more than 80 million euros based on population.

The SAC ruled in favor of the appellants on all points concluding that the procurement was unlawful and restricted competition in contradiction with the Act on Public Contracts (348/2007, as amended) and EU Directive 2004/18/EC. The SAC revoked the decision of the Market Court and the procurement decision of KL-Kuntahankinnat Oy and ordered KL-Kuntahankinnat Oy to organise a new contract award procedure subject to a conditional fine of 1 million euros.

The decision of the SAC creates a level playing field for potential tenderers and makes it clear that framework agreements cannot be used improperly to prevent, restrict or distort competition. Due to the discriminatory nature of the request for tenders and certain unproportionate mandatory requirements, the tender was in fact open only to the biggest wholesalers in the market and foreclosed the manufacturers of the products, which had no actual possibilities of participating in the tender.

Further, the decision of the SAC confirms, as argued by the appellants, that the potential tenderers have a right to receive sufficient information for the purposes of submitting a tender, including information on the actual scope of the procurement, the customers participating in the procurement and the purchases to be made by such customers in accordance with the principle of transparency.

Lawyers involved

Lotta Pohjanpalo

Partner

 

 

Share:
Image

Contact info

Eteläesplanadi 24 A
00130 Helsinki, Finland

+358 9 668 9520
+358 9 668 95 222
ww@ww.fi

Quick links

  • Our Team
  • In Focus
  • About Us
  • Expertise
  • Careers

E-invoicing

E-address: 003710525214
Operator: Apix Messaging Oy
Service ID: 003723327487


BUSINESS ID 1052521-4
VAT ID FI10525214

Legal notice
Privacy notice
General Terms and Conditions

© 2022 Waselius & Wist

This website uses cookies to compile statistical data on the use of our website in order to enable us to evaluate and improve our site. OK Decline Cookie Policy
Manage Cookies

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT